At 1235 N. Ashland Ave., the leasing page for a five-story building called The Ash lists 16 apartments. When we checked in mid-November, 15 were marked "LEASED." The one left was unit 502, a two-bedroom, two-bath plan of about 1,235 square feet, asking $4,250 a month. Next door at 1257 N. Ashland, the second half of the same development lists its two-bedrooms from $4,350 up to $5,100.
For an investor sizing up a Wicker Park two-flat, The Ash is the clearest current price signal in the neighborhood. It also shows how new rental supply arrives here: a few dozen units at a time, mostly on one stretch of Ashland, at rents well above the ones a vintage unit competes at. New construction in Wicker Park sets the top of the rent range for older buildings. It is not putting enough new units on the market to drag older buildings' rents down.
What $4,250 and up buys on Ashland
The Ash is a Noah Properties development, and its leasing site sells amenities that no 1890s two-flat has: a fitness center "Powered by Peloton & Nike," a dry sauna, a penthouse lounge, a rooftop terrace, EV charging, garage parking and elevators. The unit sizes are generous for the neighborhood. At 1235, the two-bedroom plans run 1,229 and 1,235 square feet, starting at $4,400 and $4,300. One-bedrooms come in two plans: a 1,163-square-foot unit with one and a half baths from $3,600, and a 915-square-foot plan from $3,000.
Across the four plans at 1235, that works out to roughly $3.10 to $3.60 per square foot per month, with every amenity included. The leasing page also lists two income-restricted units, a one-bedroom at $1,199 and a two-bedroom at $1,438. The ground floors add retail space, with 1,460 square feet at 1235 and 2,045 square feet at 1257, according to Urbanize Chicago's permit report.
Now compare the citywide figures. Apartment List's November 2026 report puts Chicago's median two-bedroom rent at $1,875 and its median one-bedroom at $1,723. So The Ash's cheapest market-rate two-bedroom asks about 2.3 times the citywide two-bedroom median. Even allowing for how much Wicker Park rents run above the city as a whole, that is a premium-product price, and the near-full leasing board at 1235 shows renters are paying it.
The rest of the pipeline is small, too
Most of Wicker Park's new supply comes in buildings the size of The Ash. Here is what is open, rising or permitted in and right around the neighborhood:
| Project | Developer | Units | Where it stands |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Ash, 1235 and 1257 N. Ashland | Noah Properties | 16 and 24 | Leasing |
| Wicker Park Place, 1504 W. Haddon | Wicker Park Apartments | 14 | Leasing |
| 1501 N. Ashland | JL Development | 44 | Top floor reached May 2026; opening projected late 2027 |
| 1317 N. Ashland | Base 3 Development | 8 total, 3 new | Renovation and addition |
| 1239 N. Wood | Chicago Pro Builders | 26 | Renovation permit issued January 2026 |
| Vision II, 1628 W. Division | RDM Companies | 121 | Building permit issued April 2026 |
| 1704 N. Milwaukee | Senco Properties | 60 proposed | Zoning application filed January 2026 |
Only two of these projects go above 50 units. Envoi Partners also has an adaptive-reuse plan at 1934 W. North Ave. that would put a handful of studios, one-bedrooms and two-bedrooms over ground-floor retail, according to Urbanize Chicago. Most of this pipeline sits on the stretch of Ashland between Division and North, in five-story buildings of 8 to 44 units, as reported by Chicago YIMBY and Urbanize Chicago.
Timing matters as much as size. The buildings come online one at a time. The Ash and Wicker Park Place are already on the market. The former Arandas tire shop site at 1501 N. Ashland is the next sizable delivery. Chicago YIMBY reported in May 2026 that its blockwork had reached the fifth and final floor, and an earlier YIMBY report put the opening in late 2027. Arandas will come back to the ground floor with a new showroom and offices, so the corner keeps a business the block already knew.
Where a vintage two-flat unit fits
New Wicker Park construction mostly fills the two ends of the rental market, and a typical two-flat sits between them.
At the small end, Wicker Park Place's 14 apartments are 3 studios, 3 junior one-bedrooms and 8 one-bedrooms, with no two- or three-bedroom units. Its own site lists studios from $2,000, junior one-bedrooms from $2,250 and one-bedrooms from $2,300. At the top end, The Ash's two-bedrooms ask $4,250 to $5,100 with a sauna and a parking garage.
A vintage two-flat unit has none of The Ash's elevator, sauna or garage amenities, and it rents to a different person than a Wicker Park Place studio does. Its renter is someone who wants the bedroom count and is weighing that against the price of the amenities. That is why The Ash works as a ceiling and not as a comp. An investor who underwrites a gut rehab on a Damen Avenue side street at Ashland new-construction rents is pricing in a building the unit isn't.
The ceiling is still useful. The distance between what a dated two-flat unit rents for today and what a brand-new two-bedroom asks a few blocks away is the room a value-add renovation has to work in. Kitchens, in-unit laundry, a second bath and central air are what move a vintage unit up toward that ceiling. Our guide to reading a rent roll for Chicago two-flats covers how to find the current rents on a building you're evaluating. The Ash shows where the top of the range sits in Wicker Park this fall.
What the citywide numbers add
Citywide rent data says the same thing: steady demand, without the kind of supply glut that would push the top of the range down. RealPage reported Chicago's annual rent growth at 3.3% in its October 2026 data, among the strongest of the Midwest markets. Apartment List's November 2026 report shows Chicago rents up 3.4% year over year, though October alone was down 1.1% from September. A one-month dip in October is ordinary for a Chicago fall. The year-over-year figure is the one to underwrite against.
For a two-flat owner, steady citywide growth plus a pipeline that adds a few dozen units at a time means a renovated unit is unlikely to face sudden new competition at its own price point. The 44 units at 1501 N. Ashland, projected for late 2027, are the next meaningful addition. A 2027 lease-up on Ashland is a fair assumption to build into a hold that starts this winter.
The two projects that would change the math
Vision II and 1704 N. Milwaukee are the exceptions in this pipeline, and they are the projects to track if you're buying with a five-year hold in mind.
Vision II, RDM Companies' 13-story building at 1628 W. Division St., would add 121 apartments, 25 of them affordable, with studios through three-bedrooms. Chicago YIMBY reported in April 2026 that its full building permit was issued on April 9. Urbanize Chicago later reported a tower-crane permit for the site in June. That one building has more units than The Ash, Wicker Park Place and 1501 N. Ashland combined. Because it includes two- and three-bedroom plans, it is the one project in the area that could sit closer to a renovated two-flat's renter.
At the northern edge, near Wabansia, Senco Properties' revised seven-story proposal for 1704 N. Milwaukee Ave. calls for 60 units. Chicago YIMBY reported the zoning application in January 2026. An earlier version of the plan, described by Chicago YIMBY in September 2025, ran from studios through three-bedrooms. It is still a proposal, and a proposal at the zoning stage is years from new keys.
Both projects matter because of where they sit. Division and the Milwaukee corridor are the same streets that make Wicker Park two-flats rentable in the first place, along with the Blue Line access we covered in how Blue Line access affects Wicker Park home values. If you're pricing a building within a few blocks of either site, its rent assumptions for 2028 and later should account for them. If you're pricing a building west of Damen, the Ashland pipeline is a reference point more than a competitor.
Using this on a live deal
A Wicker Park two-flat pro forma should start from the building's own rent roll, grow it at the citywide trend of a little over 3% a year that RealPage and Apartment List both reported this fall, and test the result against the new-construction ceiling on Ashland, a two-bedroom asking $4,250 to $5,100 with garage parking and a rooftop. A unit priced near that ceiling needs a renovation scope that justifies it. A unit still near its current rent roll, in a building with good bones, is where the value-add case gets made. Our breakdown of pricing and preparing a Wicker Park two-flat for sale covers the same comparison from the seller's side.
If you're underwriting a Wicker Park two-flat and want rent assumptions checked against what is actually leasing on Ashland this season, Joe Kotoch Group can walk through the rent roll, the renovation scope and the new-construction ceiling with you, building by building. Start a Strategic Conversation.